Raphael KatzService & Product Designer Back to the filing cabinet

From the checkout queue to out the door in seconds

A neighbourhood store that recognises what each customer takes off the shelf. At the exit, their basket is waiting on the kiosk: the customer checks it, pays and leaves.

NPS 62the best score of any Carrefour physical store
> 95%reliability with no human intervention
After the public opening in 2021, according to the press.
A customer walks out of the store with her shopping in hand, looking at her receipt on her phone; the Flash kiosk is free behind her
Paid in a few seconds, the customer leaves with the receipt on their phone
For
Carrefour Innovation
When
2017: student competition
2018–2021: internship, then permanent contract
My role
Service Designer. Initiated the project and led design up to the test store, then contributor (kiosks, identity, journey, apps).
Status
Open to the public in Paris, from November 2021 to February 2023

01Problem

In neighbourhood stores, time is lost at the checkout

Top-up shopping has become an almost daily habit, in neighbourhood stores where only one checkout is often open at peak times. In the queue, customers have nothing to do but wait, and the wait feels longer than it really is.

“3 minutes in the aisles, 10 minutes at the checkout.”Customer quote, field research
One customer’s perception, to scale: 3 minutes in the aisles, 10 minutes at the checkout. With Flash, 10 to 20 seconds at the kiosk are all that is left 0 5 min 10 min 13 min Today one customer’s view 3 min in the aisles 10 min at the checkout, including the wait With Flash 3 min in the aisles 10 to 20 s at the kiosk, then out 0 5 min 10 min 13 min Today one customer’s view 3 min in the aisles 10 min at the checkout, including the wait With Flash 10 to 20 s at the kiosk, then out 3 min in the aisles
To the scale of that perception: the checkout time disappears, leaving 10 to 20 s at the kiosk.

Paying itself is quick. Time is lost in the queue and scanning the items, and Flash removes both.

02Solution

A store where the checkout disappears

Isometric view of the Flash store: shelves, ceiling cameras, kiosks and exit
  1. A customer takes a product off the shelf; a ceiling camera tracks her virtual skeleton

    Walk in and help yourself, as usual

    Nothing to scan, nothing to take out of your bag.

  2. Store detail: the ceiling cameras above the shelves and the customers

    The store builds the basket

    Cameras and scales identify every product each customer takes.

  3. A customer, her shopping in her bag, in front of the Flash kiosk: the products in her basket pour virtually into the screen

    At the exit, the basket is already waiting

    It appears on the kiosk, ready to be checked.

  4. Kiosk: Payment confirmed! QR code to get the receipt

    Pay with a single tap, leave

    Card or phone on the terminal, receipt by QR code.

  5. Manager app: basket no. 103, banner The customer needs help, editable items with their quantities

    MeanwhileBehind the scenes, an employee keeps watch

    If detection gets it wrong, they correct the basket. Try the manager app

Your turn

Tap a step to jump to it, or tap the kiosk screen directly. The screens are in French, as in the store.

  1. Tap the screen

  2. Watch the basket load

  3. Check

  4. Pay

  5. Get the receipt

  6. Call for help

  7. When it doesn’t go through

    Every error offers a way out: try again, change payment method or cancel.

The prototype uses fictitious data.

03Results

Fifteen months open to the public, and the best NPS of any Carrefour store

After the 2021 opening, according to the press: Futura-Sciences and Olivier Dauvers.

NPS 62
The best score of any Carrefour physical store, home delivery excluded
> 95%
Technical reliability with no human intervention
15 months
Open to the public in Paris, from November 2021 to February 2023

In detail

How we got there

The approach, the trade-offs and what I take away from it.

04Approach

From a student competition to weekly tests

2017: a competition, then a dedicated team

Flash grew out of a partnership between Strate and Carrefour. The concept won the 2017 Carrefour Junior Innovation Day, which led to an internship and then a permanent position in the Innovation department, where a team was set up around the project.

The Flash team: the project at the centre, the dedicated team around it (two designers, including me, a Product Owner and two development teams), then three partners Flash dedicated team partners Design 2 designers, including me Product Owner tech, partners, departments Store devs in-store infrastructure Digital tools devs mobile app and checkouts AiFi product recognition Ingenico payment terminals Retail Carrefour building the test store Flash dedicated team Design 2 designers, including me Product Owner tech, partners, departments Digital tools devs mobile app and checkouts Store devs in-store infrastructure partners AiFi product recognition Ingenico payment terminals Retail Carrefour building the test store
Design covered the store, the kiosks, the apps and the signage.

What the field showed

Two peaks, one open checkout

Footfall peaks at lunchtime and between 6 and 8 pm. Staff are multi-skilled (restocking, deliveries, cleaning, the till): out of three checkouts, often only one is open.

Five months of weekly tests

Field research

Interviews and observation of real behaviour in neighbourhood stores.

Continuous iterations

An experimental store at Carrefour’s headquarters (Massy), tested every Wednesday: more than 10 observed shopping trips and 5 quick surveys. Three topics shaped the journey most: uptake of biometric payment, the size of the kiosks and customers’ fear that their basket would be wrong.

Technology benchmark

Product detection started with shelf scales, then combined scales and cameras. Towards the end, AiFi was aiming for the same accuracy with cameras alone: fitting a normal-sized store with scales would cost too much. With every gain in reliability, the screens, the messaging and the journeys were readjusted.

Flash’s workstreams move forward in parallel, and for five months a test every Wednesday makes them evolve together 2017 competition Research Set-up Iterations Validation Field research habits, payment Tech partners benchmark → AiFi Test store Retail Carrefour Payment terminals with Ingenico Digital journeys app and checkout Visual identity guidelines, messaging 5 months, a test every Wednesday led by design other teams 2017 competition Set-up Validation Research Iterations 5 months, a test every Wednesday Field research habits, payment Tech partners benchmark → AiFi Test store Retail Carrefour Payment terminals with Ingenico Digital journeys app and checkout Visual identity guidelines, messaging led by design other teams
The Wednesday tests set the pace for every workstream.
Photo of the Flash store: Flash wall, payment kiosk and customers testing the service
The test store, around 2019–2020. In the foreground, the big-screen kiosk, later dropped.

2021: opening to the public

After the test store, the project was handed to a more senior designer and I stayed on as a contributor until the decision to open a public store, then left. The service, interface and messaging launched in November 2021 are the ones we had worked on.

05Trade-offs

The design choices, and what they ruled out

kept

Shopping as usual

Because, in the field, customers knew their store by heart and went straight to the products: the service was not to change anything about how they shop.

kept

Nothing to scan

To remove the queue and the scanning, the store recognises every product taken by itself: depth cameras track each customer’s virtual skeleton without filming them (GDPR compliance checked), and the scales confirm it by weight.

dropped Baskets limited to 2 or 3 items, because of neighbourhood stores, where basket sizes vary: the first version worked in the lab, not in a store. We added cameras to the scales to detect every basket size.

kept

A basket you can check at a glance

Because in testing, customers worried their basket would be wrong. At the kiosk, their basket loads and appears: every item, its quantity, its price and the total. Customers shopping together share the same basket. The loading time doubles as a cue to get your card out.

dropped The big-screen kiosk, because of the tests: customers had to scan the screen with their eyes and got lost in it. iPad kiosks replaced it: natural reading, the face framed for biometrics, more kiosks in less space.

kept

Paying like anywhere else

Because in testing, contactless was enough: card or phone on the terminal, nothing to install, and the receipt by QR code if the customer wants it.

“The difference with contactless isn’t noticeable.”Customer test, test store

dropped Biometric payment, because of the data and the effort asked of customers. It worked, but biometric data could not stay on Carrefour’s servers: it required a dedicated app, a heavy sign-up and Bluetooth at the entrance. For customers, “too complicated for what you get”.

kept

An employee behind the scenes

Because detection could get it wrong. The customer presses Help, the employee gets the alert on the manager app and corrects the basket. Staff roles change, and the service has to plan for it.

dropped Corrections made directly on the kiosk, because of the view it gives: one checkout at a time. The manager app shows every checkout at a glance.

Try the two apps

Fictitious data and French screens; every button leads to the next screen.

The manager app

The employee gets the alert, opens the customer’s basket and corrects it. Log in, then open basket no. 103.

The biometric app Dropped

Enrolling your face and card, then paying over Bluetooth. Follow the sign-up through to the selfie.

06Lessons

What I take away

With Flash, I designed an entire service: the store, the kiosks, the apps, the signage and what staff do when something gets stuck.

A test every week in real conditions shaped the journey more than the technology did.

Next project
SeLoger — Renting out your home from your phone →
↑ Back to top